One thing we'd have to do if this is implemented, is make it crystal clear to people that if they post a critique in a no critique thread, it will be deleted. This is vital because some critiques take people ages to compile and they won't be too chuffed if it just gets zapped.
Also there's the thorny question of what actually constitutes a critique!
These are points the poetry mods are going to have to mull over before we bring this in. There ned to be clear guidelines or else it will be a mess.
I am quite sure that the many good poets we have on this forum, have no objection to a little bit of constructive criticism or advice, providing it is not done in the manner we have seen on this forum up till now.